District 9

district9I agree with my fellow reviewers in that this was one of the best movies of the summer.  I was initially surprised by the low budget feel of District 9.  Peter Jackson’s movies have been, up to this point, large on special effects (and money).  This is a definite stylistic departure for the master cinematographer who gave us Lord of the Rings, the new King Kong, and The Frighteners.  The filming style strongly reminded me of such earlier movies as 28 Days Later and Cloverfield.  However, the low budget perspective served the movie well, offering a grittiness and realism that lent greater impact to the themes presented in the movie. 

District 9 is the story of apartheid told through an alien filter.  The true genius of this movie was in getting us to take a fresh look at human rights issues and ethics in a format that most will find easier to receive and digest.  I have a friend who grew up in South Africa.  He loved District 9, claiming it reminded him of home.  He tells me the people and culture presented in the movie are very true to life and the situation that existed in District 9 was strongly reminiscent of a similar situation that existed in District 6, a black slum town that existed in Apartheid ruled South Africa. 


The way the aliens in District 9 are treated is no different than we have treated our fellow humans throughout history (and still treat them in certain places throughout the world to this day).  In District 9, the prevailing human prejudice holds that the aliens are not worthy of better treatment because they are worker drones, lesser beings, who are unable or unwilling to live at a higher standard.  Such claims have been used as an excuse for holding down other human cultures for millennia.  While many of the aliens do seem willing to lower themselves to the expectations of others, we find that this is not necessarily their true state as we come to meet an alien fully capable of using his brain and determined to rescue his people from the decadent and depraved lifestyle they have been forced into.  The anti-hero of the movie, Wikus, serves excellently as a means of connecting us to both the human and alien points of view as we see him forced to modify his preconceptions throughout the film.

My only complaint was that the movie was so focused that you missed certain wider perspectives that would’ve added even more color and realism to the story.  District 9 reveals only the thoughts, feelings and actions of a small portion of the South African city, Johannesburg.  Surely first contact with an alien race and their extraordinary technology would be an event that would draw the attention and action of the entire world.  The international scientific community would be swarming the scene, investigating the aliens and dissecting the technology.  However, it seems that South Africans are the only ones who have taken any interest in this amazing phenomenon. 

Despite Tony’s claims, I am excited by the idea of a potential sequel.  The end of the movies certainly leaves this possibility wide open.  I can only hope that many of the unanswered questions and wider perspectives lacking in District 9 will be dealt with in a sequel.

I give “District 9” 4 out of 5 Babbles.


1 Comment

Filed under Reviews

One response to “District 9

  1. M Griffith

    aye, I can agree with you that District 9 definitely felt like a social commentary on the apartheid governments, other districts, and even refugee camps, and people’s cultural reservations where humans are not being treated fairly by other human beings.

    I do have to ask you though, how is Wikus the anti-hero? He is, in my opinion, a hero in the story, because he is not static, but rather changes. He starts out representing MNU (the MULTI-NATIONAL UNION). But when he needs help from the aliens due to the infection, and is then exposed to their culture, sees how they live, and that they are capable of cognitive thinking skills, compassion, feelings, and dreams he ends up helping them. I wouldn’t call this a “modification,” but rather a complete 180 degree turn. As in the classics, this is the characteristic telltale trait of the hero, or at least the protagonist. So, I see Wikus as a hero in the story.

    Also, it just seems to me that with the story being told in the format of a movie made for audiences, that Peter Jackson (or the editors!!) made a good call in focusing on the people of Johannesburg and the aliens. There would just be too much to tell if they widened the scope of the picture to include the global interactions. And anyway, MNU was a global team, with scientific research being conducted at the MNU complex. The movie was “documented” from newscasts that sported the MNU logo, with an American television news network symbol in the lower right hand corner of the screenshots. There were also other various newscasts throughout the movie that were used as vehicles in telling the story. So, there was some scope.

    These were my observations anyways. I do have to agree with you also that District 9 leaves the open prospect of a sequel one to be looked for with excitement!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s